If you are not living under a rock there is a high probability that you have heard of eurozone debt crisis and its resurfacing in 2011. It’s being billed as the Greek Debt Crisis by the media, but intelligent analysts, investors, and traders, understand that it is far beyond Greece. It is the European Debt Crisis. Here we will try and understand the causes and implications of the same.
Throughout the 90’s Greece historically faced high rates of inflation and extreamly high debts and growing fiscal deficits because of its inefficient monetary policies ,so it was no surprise that with the formation of eurozone and floating of the euro as currency in late 90’s Greece and other European nations in similar condition like Portugal, Italy, Spain etc . were eager to join the club because:
1. All member countries would use euro as the currency which would have a common central bank (ECB in this case) backed by strong european economies such as France and Germany which meant borrowing money from other nations would be cheaper for countries such as Greece (using euro) than using their current currencies (typical interest rate on Greek drachma was 18% because of reasons stated above)
2. The grand idea was that the struggling european economies could borrow at cheap rates in order to economically develop their countries in a responsible manner. This would help them close the gap with stronger countries like Germany and France, and then all of Europe would grow more powerful.
So by 2000 Greece was allowed to join the EU and use euro as currency (though there were allegations that it cooked up the figures to meet the stringent euro criteria) .on entering of course Greece ( so did nations like Portugal, Spain, Italy, and Ireland ) borrowed money at very cheap interest rates (close to 3% as compared to 18%) but it is what they did with that money made things worse. Instead of govt expenditure on infrastructure building and capacity generation and paying up of accrued debts (as intended) the country went on a spending spree the wages of public sector employees nearly doubled, and it continued to fund one of most generous pension systems coupled with tax evasion endemic among the Greek populations resulted in non- payment of loans and debt spiraled to about €300 billion, more than the entire value of its annual GDP.
That’s just one country take the example of Spain which had the biggest housing bubble in the world. Spain now has as many unsold homes as the United States, even though the US is six times bigger. Most of these new homes were financed with capital from abroad.
Thus these countries have spent so much money and developed such irresponsible fiscal agendas that they are now having trouble paying back all those loans. To make it worse, investors are now demanding more yield in order to hold the debt of these countries. That is making it even harder for the PIIGS (Portugal, Italy, Ireland, Greece, Spain) to pay back the money they owe resulting in a sustained crisis situation.
By Suddhasheel Bhattacharya
3 comments:
Good job Suddhasheel!!! Do not put all your eggs in one basket is the conventional wisdom. Well, if all your baskets have hole then where do I put my eggs...definitely Europe is not the place I wish to be. The more G20 and IMF tries to bail them, the more they look the same. Its just a matter of time before many of the liquidity strapped companies from the Euro zone would be up for picking... The question is should such companies be picked by India Inc?
Amazing job Sud...
Well, trying to build on what Iyer Sir said, I feel India Inc should stay away from such liquidity strapped companies. Reason being, if you look at the short term, you would find buying out the companies lucrative. But if you look at the long term aspects, it would be wise not to fall into the rigmarole, as India itself is suffering from problems like fiscal indiscipline, high inflation rates etc. Though presently, employment generation might happen, the slightest crisis in Europe would prove detrimental to our economy, resulting in high attrition rates, job losses etc (Similar to the 2008 recession period). So, taking all these aspects into consideration.. i feel it would be a safe option to not try investing in Europe, though it might seem a bit too conservative.
When the EU was formed in late 90's, they made a mistake of not setting up a common fiscal authority to oversee the EU member's fiscal mismanagement which is the main cause of ongoing crisis. The current European Crisis is a mixture of three problems
1. Debt problem(Fiscal Mismanagement)
2. Financial Sector Problem( Over exposure to toxic assets)
3. Institutional structure(Common currency,Monetary policy but different fiscal policy)
All these resulted in Social Political problems for EU.
Post a Comment